WhatTheyThink    WhatTheyThink.com    Blogs    PrintPlanet


It’s Claimed Stocks are Making All-time Highs… Not Really…

By on January 31st, 2013

The business press has been writing that stock indices are at new all-time or at highs since the recession. That is, unless you adjust for inflation.

Using end-of-month historical closes, the Russell 2000 is -4.48% off its all time high, and just +1.24% since the start of the recession in December 2007. The S&P 500 is off -25.77% off its all-time high, and is still -6.71% since December 2007. The DJIA is -11.55% and -10.49% respectively. As for the NASDAQ, it’s almost -51% off its all time high, and is only +0.67% above its December 2007 close. If it wasn’t for Apple, it would probably be down -10% to -15%.

If someone dollar-cost-averaged (same dollar amount invested every month) through the recession and the sluggish and slight recovery, they probably did very well and got inflation-beating returns. The key to that is staying disciplined, especially through 2008 where the best bargains occurred and many investors panicked. I worked this out one day when it was claimed that the Wilshire 5000 had hit an all-time high. When I adjusted it for inflation, it clearly did not. All investors should be well aware that there are two significant eroders of savings: taxes and inflation. This is one reason why products like IRAs and 401k’s are so important for long term savings. They deal with the tax issue or postpone it to a later time, but they don’t manage with the inflation issue and the loss of purchasing power. Beating inflation is critical to investing.

Starting with the value of that index at December 2007, it had about a 20% return for that period with the same amount invested every month, even though it had a slight loss comparing the value of the index at those two end-points. One only earned back their money and more when they invested in a disciplined way with a small amount every month.

Bonds were the better investment thanks to “Helicopter Ben” during that period. A benefit of bond funds is that their monthly reinvestment of interest enhances any dollar-cost-averaging strategy. Very few stock funds pay monthly dividends. Most pay them quarterly, some pay them annually.

Here’s the chart showing the highs and the performance since, showing that most of the major measures of stock market performance are not at highs at all once inflation is taken into account. The all-time and December 2007 closes are adjusted using the CPI (click to enlarge):

stocks at highs 013113

  1. 4 Responses to “It’s Claimed Stocks are Making All-time Highs… Not Really…”

  2. By BJones on Feb 1, 2013 | Reply

    Dr. Joe will continue to say anything to deny the recovery. He has been anti-Obama from day one. He’s splitting hairs in his analysis here. If it had been a Republican in office during this time, his tune would be completely different, highlighting the positives instead of, as he always does, the negatives. Be more even handed, Dr. Joe!!!

  3. By Dr. Joe Webb on Feb 1, 2013 | Reply

    I don’t think you read and remember my columns. Somehow my comments in past columns and blogs and presentations about Clinton’s second term and how GDP averaged +4.4% at that time, how capital was rewarded for investment with low capital gains rates, a strong dollar, command of budget growth, and an emphasis on free trade seem to escape you.

  4. By David Schwartzbaum on Feb 1, 2013 | Reply

    Why is it that whenever someone publishes factual economic information, the narrative automatically turns agains the writer as anti-Obama, or worse? GDP growth for the end of 2012 was in the red, the unemployment rate is inching up again, and first-time unemployment claims jumped 10% this week. Add to that a crushing national debt that Congress is going to just kick down the road, again- with the President’s blessing.

    Even with all the campaign rhetoric of “taxing the rich”, the US government already spent more on the Hurricane Sandy relief package than it will collect in the new taxes- and it is only February. Personal income tax rates are going to be hiked again, this time for the not-so-rich. If GDP dips this quarter, we are officially in recession, not recovery. In actuality, there is no recovery.

  5. By Dr. Joe Webb on Feb 4, 2013 | Reply

    One more comment re investing where there are some gains. WSJ had a good article today that reviews the tax implications of investments. Some funds invest in ways that may create tax obligations that you are not expecting (and hence should be reserved for retirement accounts). “How New Taxes Affect Fund Investors” http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887323596204578242050105857938.html